The following is a list of myths in Bully.
Several x-rays of living things with weird anatomy like a heavily-bent spine and a skull like an alien's can be found in the asylum; in the same room is a skeleton of what appears to be an extraterrestrial, with the head matching an x-ray on the floor. There is a framed photograph in the Library of a bald-headed scientist (widely believed by fans to be Dr. Watts) standing next to a being with the head of a Grey hanging next to the staircase on the first floor; this same photograph is found in the asylum's reception area.
There is an oddly shaped triangle that can be seen in the sky above Bullworth. It is different from both the airplane and the birds. As there are photos of aliens and alien-like skeletons in the Asylum, some have speculated that it is an alien spacecraft. Regardless of whether it is related to aliens or not, it is still technically an Unidentified Flying Object, i.e. a UFO. A possibility is that this is actually an unused in-game blip.
The Hobo is abducted by what appears to be a UFO, after Jimmy gives him the last transistor.
McInnis can be heard talking about a haunted papermill. Apparently, the police are too afraid to go up to the attic of the mill. There is no actual papermill in town; it is possible that they are referring to one of the various abandoned warehouses in New Coventry, the industrial park, or the sawmill. It is also possible that it is in reference to something that was removed from the game in the final version.
It is most likely, however, that the talk of the papermill being haunted is simply McInnis's paranoia, since he often talks about supernatural and superstitious stuff, as well as putting too much stock in astrological signs.
In addition to the alien photos in the Asylum, there is also an x-ray of a human-like skull attached to a horizontal spine. In addition, there are strange howling sounds out in the woods at night, although there are many more likely explanations for this than werewolves. Dogs howl, as do coyotes, which are native to the New England area.
Gary Smith is not a werewolf
There are persistent false rumours that Gary Smith is a werewolf. The rumors claim that a scar on the werewolf mask worn by Trevor at Halloween (and later acquirable by Jimmy) has a scar on the right eye identical to Gary's scar. They do both have scars, but the scars are not identical - Gary's scar goes diagonally across his eye to the corner of his jaw, and the werewolf's scar goes straight down to the bridge of its nose. All the other alleged evidence, such as the x-rays, photos and howling, don't relate to Gary in any way.
Rumour has it that the ghost of a female student can be seen in the girl's dorm attic or in the bathroom of the gym at night. The student apparently died during her time at Bullworth. No photographs or videos have surfaced regarding this, nor is there a ghost in the data files.
It is believed that the mermaid from the freakshow sometimes appears in in the waters of Blue Skies Industrial Park near the sunken boat.
Some suggest that the boat in the display is the same as the one near the docks.
The sound of a running chainsaw and laughter can be heard coming from a rundown house in Blue Skies Industrial Park, at any time of the day. Snoring can also be heard, and smoke can be seen inside as well.
Strange voices in buildings
In the run-down houses and apartment buildings in eastern New Coventry and near the bridge to Blue Skies, voices can be heard at any time of the day and night. The words are muffled and full of echoes, although a young boy yelling "no" can be heard clearly.
In the ambience files, these are referred to as playground ambience and kids playing, although there are no playgrounds or child parks seen in Bullworth. It is possible that the neighborhood where these voices are heard was meant to be a children's playground during one point in development.
Demonstrably false "evidence"
The following is a list of things people have claimed in support of these myths that are demonstrably fraudulent.
- There is no crashed UFO on the roof of the asylum.
- No werewolves, aliens or ghosts have been located in the data files.
- Bully Myths and Legends Series - Ghost Girl, Werewolf and UFOs.
- Bully Myths on Youtube - odd skeletons, photos and X-rays found in the Happy Volts Asylum.